Opening the File Drawer: Assessing and Understanding Publication Bias in the Economic, Behavioral and Social Sciences by Utilizing two German Academic Access Panels (PubBias)
Abstract
Publication bias can be regarded as the publication (or non-publication) of study results due to the direction or strength. That is when, for example, statistically significant results are more likely to be published than statistically non-significant results. Consequently, publication bias hinders the assessmentof the true state of knowledge on a particular research question, resulting inscientific debates and political decisions that are based on false orinadequate scientific evidence. Several factors impact the emergence of publication bias, most importantly the actors directlyinvolved: authors, editors, and reviewers. In addition, the disciplinary andcultural background affects the likelihood and extent of publication bias aswell. In our project,we plan to focus on the various steps of researchers’ decision-makingprocesses, which may lead to the publication of selected results while leavingother results in the “file drawer.” The project has two main objectives: (I)First, it aims to measure the extent of publication bias for the economic, behavioral, and social sciences in Germany. This will be accomplished by contrasting published and unpublished GESIS Panel and SOEP-Innovation Sample (SOEP-IS) study submissions. (II) Second, building upon existing theoretical frameworks on the causes of publication bias, we will empirically test the derived hypotheses and (if necessary) adjust and/or extent the current theoretical models.
Runtime
2023-08-01 – 2026-07-31Partner
- SOEP – The Socio-Economic Panel, DIW – German Institute of Economic Research