Women’s experiences of racial microaggressions in STEMM workplaces and the importance of white allyship
Autor/in:
Moore, Robyn; Nash, Meredith
Quelle: International Journal of Gender, Science and Technology; Vol 13, No 1 (2021), (2021)
Inhalt: This article explores how gender interacts with race, ethnicity and/or culture to structure the microaggressions experienced by visibly and culturally diverse women in Australian Science, Technology, Engineering, Mathematics and Medicine (STEMM) organisations. We focus on these women’s experiences to disrupt the normative erasure of race from the workplace diversity context. We conducted 30 semi-structured interviews with women in academia, industry and government who self-identify as women of colour or as culturally diverse. We use an intersectional lens to show that the challenges experienced by visibly and culturally diverse women cannot simply be subsumed under gender. Rather, race and gender intersect to create overlapping and interdependent systems of discrimination and disadvantage. These issues are largely unintelligible in STEMM fields as science is positioned as gender- and race-neutral. Consequently, despite their devastating impact, racial microaggressions may be invisible to members of the dominant racial group—those most likely to be the peers and managers of visibly and culturally diverse women. White managers and peers can act as allies to women of colour in STEMM by respecting and amplifying their concerns. Learning to recognise and confront racial microaggressions can help make science workplaces more inclusive of all scientists.
Inhalt: When it comes to gender equity in the workplace, many organizations focus largely on hiring more women. But to achieve more equitable representation, it’s also critical to examine disparities in how employees are evaluated and promoted once they’re on board. In this piece, the authors discuss their recent research on this topic, which found that competitive evaluation systems in which employees are ranked against one another can cause men to perform better and women to perform worse (on a task for which their performance would otherwise be roughly the same). They suggest that this likely stems from deeply-ingrained stereotypes that lead men to believe they are better than women in competitive environments, and that lead women to prioritize avoiding harming others. Based on these findings, the authors argue that organizations should build awareness of the potential harms of ranking employees, and that they should consider either adapting or totally overhauling existing performance evaluation systems to focus more on individual progress, and less on social comparisons.
Quelle: Deutscher Musikrat; deutsches musikinformationszentrum (miz); Bonn, 2021.
Inhalt: Die Orchestererhebung, die das Deutsche Musikinformationszentrum (miz) unter allen öffentlich finanzierten Orchestern durchgeführt hat, schlüsselt erstmals detailliert auf, wie hoch der Anteil von Frauen und Männern sowohl in den einzelnen Stimmgruppen als auch in den Dienststellungen ist. Im Ergebnis zeigt sich, dass Frauen mit 39,6 Prozent stark vertreten sind. In den Führungspositionen sind sie hingegen unterrepräsentiert, ganz besonders in den Spitzenorchestern. Dort liegt ihr Anteil bei 21,9 Prozent, während er im Durchschnitt aller Orchester 30 Prozent ausmacht.
Die Daten der miz-Orchestererhebung sind im Ergebnisbericht der Studie sowie auf dem Infografikposter "Am Pult der Zeit!?" nachzulesen.
Der Bericht weist Methodik, Daten und Analysen der Orchestererhebung aus. Die Ergebnisse sind nach Stimmgruppe und Dienststellung aufgeschlüsselt. In der Analyse werden zudem Orchestermerkmale wie die tarifliche Eingruppierung berücksichtigt.
Schlagwörter:Künstlerische Hochschule; Musik; Musikerin; Musikhochschule; quantitative Analyse; Statistik
CEWS Kategorie:Arbeitswelt und Arbeitsmarkt, Geschlechterverhältnis
Mentoring as affective governmentality: Shame, (un)happiness, and the (re)production of masculine leadership
Autor/in:
Sandager, Jette
Quelle: Gend Work Organ (Gender, Work and Organization), (2021)
Inhalt: This article contributes to current discussions on the effectiveness of mentoring as a gender equality tool, but also focuses on the emotions and bodily (dis)comforts mentoring produces in addition to linguistic discourses, thus offering a novel take on how the tool operates. Drawing on a case study of a Danish mentoring program aimed at establishing the organizational space of leadership as more gender equal, the article demonstrates how, in producing shame and (un)happiness, mentoring (re)produces leadership as an organizational space dominated by masculine norms and work practices. The findings of the article support literature arguing that mentoring is an ineffective gender equality tool. However, the article does not entirely discard mentoring for this purpose, instead suggesting that scholars and practitioners look to literature on queered forms of mentoring for inspiration on how to use mentoring as a tool that carries the potential of truly promoting gender equality.
Herausgeber/in:
Lambertsson, Björk, Eva; Eschenbach, Jutta; Wagner, Johanna M.
Quelle: Waxmann, 2021.
Inhalt: „This collection brings together scholars from various disciplines to ask fundamental questions concerning how women handle the manifold impediments placed before them as they simply attempt to live full human lives. The collection explores narratives of women – real and fictional – who fight against these barriers, who succumb to them, who remain unaware of them, or choose to ignore them. It explores the ways we read women in cultural Production, and how women are read in society. We assert the obstacles constructed into the very fabric of societies against fifty percent of the population are unfair, be they hindrances for women to attain their goals, encumbrances that limit women’s speech and societal participation – communal and artistic – or hindrances that prohibit specific behaviors and images of women.”
Schlagwörter:equality; fairness; motherhood; patriarchy; stereotype; work
CEWS Kategorie:Arbeitswelt und Arbeitsmarkt, Gleichstellungspolitik
Dokumenttyp:Sammelwerk
Gender Wage and Longevity Gaps and the Design of Retirement Systems
Autor/in:
Barigozzi, Francesca; Cremer, Helmuth; Lozachmeur, Jean-Marie
Quelle: (IZA Discussion Paper), 2021.
Inhalt: "We study the design of pension benefits for male and female workers. Women live longer than men but have a lower wage. Individuals can be single or live in couples who pool their incomes. Social welfare is utilitarian but an increasing concave transformation of individuals’ lifetime utilities introduces the concern for redistribution between individuals with different life-spans. We derive the optimal direction of redistribution and show how it is affected by a gender neutrality rule. With singles only, a simple utilitarian solution implies redistribution from males to females. When the transformation is sufficiently concave redistribution may or may not be reversed. With couples only, the ranking of gender retirement ages is always reversed when the transformation is sufficiently concave. Under gender neutrality pension schemes must be self-selecting. With singles only this implies distortions of retirement decision and restricts redistribution across genders. With couples, a first best that implies a lower retirement age for females can be implemented by a gender-neutral system. Otherwise, gender neutrality implies equal retirement ages and restricts the possibility to compensate the shorter-lived individuals. Calibrated simulations show that when singles and couples coexist, gender neutrality substantially limits redistribution in favor of single women and fully prevents redistribution in favor of male spouses."
Pay Gaps in the National Health Service: Observability and Disclosure
Autor/in:
Mumford, Karen; Aguirre, Edith; Einarsdóttir, Anna; Lockyer, Bridget; Sayli, Melisa; Smith, Benjamin A.
Quelle: (IZA Discussion Paper), 2021.
Inhalt: "Studies of the relationship between sexual orientation and pay have faced difficulties applying standard models of discrimination if orientation is not observable. Analogously, behavioural explanations of pay based on models of gender linked within-household specialization may not be as relevant in a nonheterosexual context. This article analyses pay gaps using information including earnings, gender, LGB identity, coupling status, and the disclosure of sexual orientation in English National Health Service (NHS) workplaces. The results reveal a robust gender pay gap of 4% in favour of males, but no overall LGB pay gap compared to heterosexuals. The latter is due to similar-sized offsetting effects from disclosure on LGB pay relative to comparable heterosexuals. Amongst LGB employees, disclosure is associated with 13% more pay, with three quarters of this gap related to unexplained differences in returns to observable characteristics. Supportive workplace practices are strongly associated with increased probability of disclosure, especially the availability of a LGB workplace network."
Schlagwörter:gender pay gap; National Health Service; sexual orientation
Gender Differences in Job Search and the Earnings Gap: Evidence from Business Majors
Autor/in:
Cortes, Patricia; Pan, Jessica; Pilossoph, Laura; Zafar, Basit
Quelle: (IZA Discussion Paper), 2021.
Inhalt: "To understand gender differences in the job search process, we collect rich information on job offers and acceptances from past and current undergraduates of Boston University’s Questrom School of Business. We document two novel empirical facts: (1) there is a clear gender difference in the timing of job offer acceptance, with women accepting jobs substantially earlier than men, and (2) the gender earnings gap in accepted offers narrows in favor of women over the course of the job search period. Using survey data on risk preferences and beliefs about expected future earnings, we present empirical evidence that the patterns in job search can be partly explained by the higher levels of risk aversion displayed by women and the higher levels of overoptimism (and slower belief updating) displayed by men. We develop a job search model that incorporates these gender differences in risk aversion and (over)optimism about prospective offers. Our counterfactual exercises show that simple policies such as eliminating “exploding offers” by allowing students to hold onto offers for an additional month, or providing them with accurate information about the labor market, can reduce the gender gap significantly."
Inhalt: "We examine employer preferences for hiring men vs women using 160,000 job ads posted on an online job portal in India, linked with more than 6 million applications. We apply machine learning algorithms on text contained in job ads to predict an employer’s gender preference. We find that advertised wages are lowest in jobs where employers prefer women, even when this preference is implicitly retrieved through the text analysis, and that these jobs also attract a larger share of female applicants. We then systematically uncover what lies beneath these relationships by retrieving words that are predictive of an explicit gender preference, or gendered words, and assigning them to the categories of hard and soft-skills, personality traits, and flexibility. We find that skills related female-gendered words have low returns but attract a higher share of female applicants while malegendered words indicating decreased flexibility (e.g., frequent travel or unusual working hours) have high returns but result in a smaller share of female applicants. This contributes to a gender earnings gap. Our findings illustrate how gender preferences are partly driven by stereotypes and statistical discrimination."
Sexual Orientation and Earnings : A Meta-Analysis 2012-2020
Autor/in:
Drydakis, Nick
Quelle: (IZA Discussion Paper), 2021.
Inhalt: "This meta-analysis utilizes 24 papers published between 2012-2020 that focus on earnings differences by sexual orientation. The papers cover the period between 1991 and 2018, and countries in Europe, North America and Australia. The meta-analysis indicates that gay men earned less than heterosexual men. Lesbian women earned more than heterosexual women, while bisexual men earned less than heterosexual men. Bisexual women earned less than heterosexual women. According to the meta-analysis, in data sets after 2010, gay men and bisexual men and women continue to experience earnings penalties, while lesbian women continue to experience earnings premiums. The meta-regression estimates indicate relationships between study characteristics and the estimated earnings effects for sexual minorities. For instance, regions, sexual minority data set sizes, and earnings classifications influence the outcomes. The persistence of earnings penalties for gay men and bisexual men and women in the face of anti-discrimination policies represents a cause for concern and indicates the need for comprehensive legislation and workplace guidelines to guarantee that people receive fair pay and not experience any form of workplace inequality simply because of their sexual orientation."
Schlagwörter:Bisexuality; gay; heterosexual; salary; sexual orientation
CEWS Kategorie:Arbeitswelt und Arbeitsmarkt, Diversity